Most Important Job Interview Question – “When Have You Failed?”

SmartRecruiters Bulb

The most important job interview question is, “When have you failed? Tell me about it.” The answer shows how one portrays the self to others, and what it’ll be like to work together. A job seeker can answer this question in one of three ways:

(1) beat around the bush, working the conversation to another topic,

(2) tell you story of how one almost failed but overcame it,

or (3) tell you a story of how one – for a reason or another – has failed before.

The world of work will not go as predictions of production indicate. It took me about 10-15 interviews with job seekers to learn, this is the most important question to ask a job candidate. Let’s examine the possibilities of what you can learn from answers to The Most Important Job Interview Question – “When Have You Failed?”

failure one

If the candidates beats around the bush and is unable tell you of a professional failure, you have learned that the candidate is one of the following:

(1) uncomfortable with the transparency of admitting failure (which may lead to an unwillingness to own up to mistakes committed in your company)

(2) in disbelief of failure’s existence,

(3) incapable of demonstrating the ability to explain the learnings from his or her failures in a traditional manner (Failure is unimportant. It takes courage to make a fool of yourself.);

or maybe, (4) one has never truly failed before.

This answer does not necessarily mean you should not hire this person. You have learned of their mindset, and there is a job for every mindset. Maybe one is too shy to admit a mistake in a job interview? Or did the candidate seamlessly redirect the conversation to another relevant topic? If so, the candidate has demonstrated tremendous skill and character flaw in the same maneuver. No one is perfect. Many jobs favor the ability to communicate without admitting mistakes.

failure two

If the candidate tells you a story of how one almost failed but overcame it, you have learned that the candidate is one of the following:

(1) portrayer of the world in a permanently positive view (possibly doesn’t believe in failure),

(2) still not fully comfortable with the transparency of admitting failure but willing to meet you halfway (possibly doesn’t believe in failure; results! Why, man I have gotten a lot of results. I know several thousand things that won’t work.),

(3) able to explain how one solved whatever difficulty of problem the example described;

or maybe, (4) one has never truly failed before (possibly does not believe in failure; if we will be quiet and ready enough, we shall find compensation in every disappointment).

Don’t underestimate the impact positivity can have on persistence and collaboration. Failure will never overtake me if my determination to succeed is strong enough. Ask yourself, why did the job seeker choose to tell me this specific failure? Pay close attention to how one solved the problem, turning the failure into a success, so to speak. Hire this person if their example is the type of problem solving the position demands.

Failure three

If the candidate tells you a story of how one – for a reason or another –  has failed before, you have learned that the candidate can:

(1) talk about a time when one has failed, and call it failure,

(2) talk about a time when one has failed, call it failure, and explain what one learned to become a better worker (failure is success if we learn from it.)

(3) talk about a time when one has failed and blame someone else for the failure;

or maybe, (4) the candidate has never failed before and is lying (the only real failure in life is not to be true to the best one knows.)

This may be the most candid answer of a well rounded human being, but it is not necessarily the right hire for every position. Will this candidate detail the wrong failure to an important client, partner or reporter? That question can only be answered by their body of work and the rest of the interview. To tell a true story of failing in a job interview is to understand that failure is the condiment that gives success its flavor. I like working with these people, on most projects. However many issues involve multiple people, and I see a red flag if the job seeker blames the majority of the failure on another person.  



Everyday, learning from failures changes how I share input in the hiring process. As always, I learned from that to write this. I like to work hands on with people who answer with a story of almost failing but overcoming it, or a story of how one – for a reason or another – has truly failed before, but that’s just me, and I also understand the value in hiring a person who beats around the bush, working his or her way to a topic that isn’t “failure.”

I failed yesterday. And the day before that. And who knows maybe it’s a failure to say the most important job interview question is …

Tell me about a time you failed

David Smooke fails everyday.


Watch the product tour to see how our enterprise recruiting software can empower you to find, engage and hire great talent.
Share on LinkedInTweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+
David Smooke Director Content Marketing, SmartRecruiters David Smooke is the SmartRecruiters Director of Content Marketing & Social Media. He runs the SmartRecruiters Blog.
More posts

New Marketplace Additions: December 2016

If you haven’t seen our Marketplace yet, it’s the easiest way to add integrations to SmartRecruiters. We’re always adding new partners, and if you don’t see your preferred partner yet, request it in the Marketplace to make SmartRecruiters your top-to-bottom Talent Acquisition Suite.

In December 2016, we added three new partners, including eSkillFirst Advantage, and T&CC. For more information on these great partners, read below:

read more…

The Essential “Culture Fit” Interview Questions

After four years of startup life, I’ve come to hate the question, “is this candidate a culture fit?”. I hate it almost as much as I am repulsed by the over-used word “hacking.” I hear it every day and it makes me cringe!

Now don’t get me wrong: culture is important. A company’s culture is its personality. It is the environment in which the team operates, which is affected by its mission, goals, and leadership.

In fact, it’s what sets startups apart from the rest of the business world. It’s certainly not the size or age of the company that determines whether it is a startup or not, as there are tiny bureaucratic companies and giant public companies with startup cultures.

So how do companies make sure their culture succeeds when they add a new hire to the team? read more…

Are You Using These Recruiter Training Tips To Optimize Your Hiring Team?

Filling a position can be a tough task. You have to find the right talent, but you don’t want just anyone to sit at that desk. You need fresh talent that is going to take your company to new heights, and be a great asset to your team.

While you may be busy, you might delegate some of your recruiting tasks to other recruiters. At the same time, they probably have their hands full, and might not be taking the time to bring in best and the brightest to review. That being said, Hiring Managers have a lot of power.

If they can provide candidates with a positive, individual experience during the recruitment process, they can bring in excellent new hires and make you look like the great employer that you truly are. However, if your Hiring Managers are making some common recruiting mistakes, you will have a hard time finding those superstar hires.

The good news is that there is any easy way for you to help your Hiring Managers avoid these pitfalls and end up with the best talent the job market has to offer… read more…